Yes, it’s February… but we finally made it happen. Nathan is joined by returning guest Mark Blitch to count down their Top TV Shows of 2025, from prestige heavy-hitters to pure comfort-watch chaos.
Along the way, they compare notes on what held up (and what fell off), talk legacy seasons (The Bear, The White Lotus), debate slow-burn patience tests (Pluribus), celebrate the beautifully unhinged brilliance of The Rehearsal and share a few curveballs.
Plus: honorable mentions, a few “what were they thinking?” disappointments and the shows they wish more people were watching.
Listen to This Episode:
Spotify | Apple Podcasts | Riverside | YouTube
Nathan’s Picks:
10. The White Lotus (S3) - HBO Max
9. The Righteous Gemstones (S4) - HBO Max
8. Stumble (S1) - NBC/Peacock
7. The Chair Company (S1)
6. Task (S1) - HBO Max
5. Pluribus (S1) - Apple TV
4. English Teacher (S2) - Hulu
3. America's Team: The Gambler and His Cowboys - Netflix
2. The Rehearsal (S2) - HBO Max
1. Adolescence - Netflix
Mark’s Picks:
10. Dexter: Resurrection (S1) - Paramount Plus
9. The Bear (S4) - Hulu
8. Nobody Wants This (S2) - Netflix
7. The Chair Company (S1) - HBO Max
6. Severance (S2) - Apple TV
5. Pluribus (S1) - Apple TV
4. Stranger Things (S5) - Netflix
3. Alien: Earth (S1) - Hulu
2. The Studio (S1) - Apple TV
1. The Rehearsal (S2) - HBO Max
Nathan’s Honorable Mentions:
Death by Lightning - Netflix
The Four Seasons (S1) - Netflix
Nobody Wants This (S2) - Netflix
Ruby & Jodi: A Cult of Sin and Influence - HBO Max
Stick - Apple TV
Good, but a little dissapointed:
Hacks (S4) - HBO Max
The Paper - NBC/Peacock
Sirens - Netflix
The Studio - Apple TV
Horrible
The Golden Bachelor (S2) - ABC/Hulu
The Hunting Wives (S1) - Netflix
Mark’s Honorable Mentions:
Chad Powers (S1) - Hulu
Peacemaker (S2) - HBO Max
The Righteous Gemstones (S4) - HBO Max
Tires (S1) - Netflix
Welcome to Derry (S1) - HBO Max
Welcome to Wrexham (S4) - Hulu
The White Lotus (S3) - HBO Max
Good, but a little dissapointed:
Ironheart (S1) - Disney+
The Last of Us (S2) - HBO Max
Yellow Jackets (S3) - Paramount Plus
