Overall Rating: ★★★★★
Pop Culture Footprint: While it never broke through to the mainstream, Frances Ha helped define a particular era of independent cinema that favored sharp dialogue, complicated friendships and deeply human characters over traditional storytelling. It also helped solidify Greta Gerwig as one of the most exciting creative voices of her generation.
Rewatchability: 5 out of 5 — This is the definition of a comfort movie. I could watch it at any time of day and know I’d walk away with a smile on my face.
Makes You Think: You'll reflect on your twenties with a mixture of nostalgia and relief. It's a wonderful reminder of the freedom, uncertainty and optimism of early adulthood, even if you wouldn't necessarily want to relive it.
Conversation Starter: Get a group of old friends together after watching this, and I guarantee the conversation will turn into swapping stories about terrible apartments, questionable career decisions and the ridiculous things we did while trying to figure out adulthood.
Holds Up: Completely. The black-and-white cinematography gives the film a timeless quality, even as its technology and cultural references firmly place it in the early 2010s. If anything, the themes of friendship, ambition and finding your place in the world have only become more relatable with age.
Where I'd Place It: Higher than I originally expected. Frances Ha is a terrific representation of the dialogue-driven indie comedies that have helped define 21st-century cinema. Its simplicity is its greatest strength, and I suspect it will only continue to grow on me with each viewing.
★ ★★★★
#90 – Frances Ha (2012)
From The New York Times: The 100 Best Movies of the 21st Century
Directed by Noah Baumbach
It’s been over seven years since I originally saw Frances Ha, and though I didn’t write a review at the time, I gave it four stars. I’m also pretty sure it was the film responsible for sending me down the Noah Baumbach rabbit hole and turning me into a huge fan of anything Greta Gerwig touched.
Though Baumbach and Gerwig started dating in 2011 (eventually marrying in 2023), they have undoubtedly brought out the best in each other professionally, collaborating on several feature films, including this one and Barbie. I’ve always been drawn to dialogue-driven indie comedies, and Baumbach and Gerwig are terrific writers who create lived-in characters with dialogue that is smart and witty without ever talking down to the audience (unlike a Woody Allen movie).
The story is rather simple. We follow Frances (Gerwig), an aspiring professional dancer in New York City who can’t seem to escape the role of an apprentice. As she struggles to achieve her dream, she bounces between apartments, roommates and even dorm rooms, all while trying to figure out what life has in store for her.
What struck me most about Frances Ha this time around is just how enjoyable it is. It perfectly encapsulates that coming-of-age moment in your mid-20s when you’re desperately trying to find your footing in the adult world. Sure, you’re paying rent and never quite feel like you have solid ground beneath your feet, but you still have the energy to go out at night and the freedom to watch a movie in the middle of a weekday.
You don’t have to have lived in New York to appreciate Frances’s journey. She’s incredibly lovable and relatable, yet you can easily recognize the qualities that might drive other people crazy. There’s a certain naïveté to Frances, particularly in her determination to keep going when others might have thrown in the towel. But she also has an endearing ability to appreciate the present, even when her future looks nothing like she imagined.
Now that my two girls are getting older, I’m beginning to appreciate how female friendships operate on an entirely different level. A major part of Frances Ha revolves around Frances’s perceived “loss” of her best friend, Sophie (Mickey Sumner), as Sophie’s relationship with her boyfriend, Patch (Patrick Heusinger), deepens.
The beats of their friendship almost mimic a romantic comedy, complete with heartbreak, jealousy and reconciliation. I think most people can relate to having that one best friend who seems to figure out life before you do, and how difficult it can be to redefine a friendship when your lives begin moving in different directions. This is where Gerwig’s influence really shines, capturing the complicated ups and downs of friendships as we navigate our twenties and begin carving out lives of our own.
The beautiful black-and-white cinematography not only captures a New York City emerging from the aughts but also preserves a fascinating moment when screens were beginning to take over our everyday lives. Watching movies on a laptop in bed or listening to your iPod on the subway had become the norm, and I loved reflecting on how those technological advancements changed the way I consumed movies and music.
I also want to give a special shoutout to all the couples who decided to start a blog together, convinced it was going to catch on. I wish I could say I wasn't guilty of the same thing, but much like Sophie and Patch’s travel blog, the imarriedacritic blog I started with my wife never quite took off. We were clearly ahead of our time. Or perhaps the world just wasn't ready for our brilliance.
Frances Ha is also a smorgasbord of talented young actors who have gone on to do some incredible things. The casting is fantastic, and it’s especially fun to revisit early performances from Adam Driver, Michael Zegen, Grace Gummer and Justine Lupe. Baumbach has always been terrific at directing actors, and it’s clear he has an eye for talent and a knack for bringing authentic voices out of his performers.
On the surface, Frances Ha might not strike you as an unforgettable film because everything about it feels so effortless and lived-in. It’s not necessarily the kind of movie that immediately springs to mind when debating the greatest films of the century. But the more I mulled over what I had watched, the harder it became to find anything wrong with it.
Sometimes brilliance doesn’t have to be complex.
There’s something remarkably difficult about making a film that is thoughtful and reflective while still being funny and an absolute joy to spend time with. Baumbach and Gerwig make it look effortless. Frances Ha is a reminder that art doesn't have to be emotionally exhausting to be meaningful, and I couldn't help but finish the film with a smile on my face.
More than anything, I enjoyed remembering a time in my life when I was ready to take on the world, before the responsibilities of adulthood had worn me down quite so much. There's a wonderful optimism to Frances, even when everything seems to be falling apart around her. She reminds us that the dreams we have for ourselves rarely unfold exactly as planned, but the unexpected detours often lead us to where we're supposed to be.
Frances Ha is ultimately a film about learning to appreciate the friendships, experiences and fleeting moments that shape us along the way. We make mistakes, we grow apart, we stumble into adulthood and sometimes we discover that the life we end up with is even better than the one we originally imagined.
And if we can learn to laugh at ourselves along the way, all the better.